Bob McCloskey Insurance was founded in 1975 by Bob McCloskey Sr., as a general agency selling property and casualty, as well as life and health products.

The initial incursion into the special risk accident field consisted of selling to K-12 schools and school districts in NJ, then adding youth baseball and football leagues. The agency grew, and sales to colleges were added; first, for intercollegiate athletic programs, then college accident and sickness plans.

In 1984, straight from Rutgers University, Rob McCloskey joined the agency, initially handling the Agency’s P & C products. Subsequently, Rob took over the sales in Massachusetts and over the years became involved in all phases of the operation; which now includes a full line of accident plans for youth sports, organizations, private and parochial schools, camps, and sports liability, as well as the K-12 and college plans.

It became apparent that in order to provide full service and satisfy and service our clients, it was necessary to administer and pay the claims for these programs, and our TPA operation was started in 1986. It was made a separate entity, BMI Benefits, in 2004.

Over the years we have sold and administered plans and programs for companies such as Reliance Standard Life, State Mutual, Sentry, Equitable, John Hancock, CNA, BCS and Monumental.

We currently administer plans for AIG, Chubb, Hartford, Cigna, and Standard Security Life from our office in Matawan, NJ, in all states.